This submit might include affiliate hyperlinks. As an Amazon Affiliate, I earn from qualifying purchases. Please learn my disclosure.
My grilled cheese with pickles is the final word alternative for pickle lovers and anybody craving a traditional grilled cheese with a twist. The right mixture of crunchy toasted bread, tangy pickles, and melted, gooey cheese makes this fast and straightforward lunch irresistible.
Now I do know what you is likely to be considering.. are pickles good on grilled cheese?! Dill pickles on grilled cheese might look like an odd mixture, however belief me, it’s wonderful! They really make a terrific pair as a result of the marginally candy, tremendous tangy taste of the pickles enhances the salty, creamy, extra fatty taste within the cheese very well. When heated collectively, their flavors mix to make the proper mixture!
Similar to the standard grilled cheese, my spin on a nostalgic lunch nonetheless goes completely with a heat bowl of immediate pot tomato soup or vegan tomato soup, potato chips, parmesan truffle fries, or air fried candy potato fries.
Buttery and crispy on the surface, with melted cheese on the within, this dill pickle grilled cheese sandwich recipe is at all times a good suggestion!
My recipe for grilled cheese with pickles is a enjoyable twist on a nostalgic American traditional! It’s extremely straightforward to make and excellent for these days after I want one thing fast and satisfying. I additionally recognize how easy it’s to customise—there are such a lot of variations that may cater to totally different tastes and dietary wants.
I like the crisp texture the bread will get from being toasted on the skillet with a bit of butter. The sandwich is cooked simply sufficient for the cheese slices to soften, so the primary chew is heat, tangy, and so satisfying.
Wealthy cheddar cheese and salty dill pickles make this sandwich a favourite for everybody, particularly pickle fanatics.
What’s nice is that this sandwich is prepared in simply 20 minutes, making it a go-to choice for critical consolation meals on busy weeknights or as a fast lunch for the kiddos.
It’s additionally family-friendly, so everybody on the desk is pleased. Plus, with just a few swaps, this sandwich might be made vegan and gluten-free, which is ideal for accommodating totally different dietary preferences.
Newest Recipe Video!
🥘 Components
My melty grilled cheese and pickle sandwich is made with simply 5 easy components! Right here’s what you want:
Entire Wheat Bread: I take advantage of wheat bread as an alternative of the standard white bread for this cheese and pickle toastie as a result of it’s a more healthy choice with extra complete grains and fiber. Actually, it tastes simply pretty much as good as white bread when it’s grilled! Nonetheless, you need to use any form of bread for this sandwich—white bread, gluten-free bread, sprouted wheat bread, buckwheat bread, or slices of sourdough bread are all nice choices.
Mayo: Mayo provides creaminess and a delicate tangy taste to my grilled cheese pickle sandwich. For a decrease calorie and decrease fats choice, I take advantage of gentle mayo.
Gentle Or Sharp Cheddar Cheese Slices: I want cheddar cheese for its sharper, extra highly effective taste in comparison with different forms of cheese like American cheese, which is usually used for grilled cheese sandwiches. I discover that sharp cheddar melts superbly, making a gooey, clean texture that binds the sandwich collectively completely. The distinction between the daring cheddar and the opposite components makes every chew extra flavorful and satisfying. Whether or not I’m utilizing a traditional cheddar or a extra aged selection, the hot button is to select one with a robust taste profile that holds up properly throughout grilling.
Dill Pickles: Hamburger dill chips are the star of the present! Bread and butter pickles are additionally an choice. Examine the variations part under for different tasty concepts!
Softened Butter: Butter is what makes a grilled cheese and pickles sandwich completely crispy and golden brown on the surface.
🔪 How To Make A Grilled Cheese With Pickles
Learn to make my dill pickle and grilled cheese sandwich recipe! See the recipe card under for the whole steps.
Dry Dill Pickles: I pat dry the sliced dill pickles with a kitchen paper towel and set them apart.
Start Meeting: I begin assembling the sandwiches by putting two slices of bread on a chopping board and spreading a layer of mayo on every slice.
Add Pickles: I layer the sliced pickles and a slice of cheese on high of the mayo.
Prime Sandwich, Butter Bread: I high every sandwich with the remaining bread slices and butter the surface of every piece of bread with the softened butter.
Warmth Skillet, Prepare dinner Sandwich: I warmth a big skillet over medium-low warmth, place the sandwiches on the skillet buttered aspect down, and cook dinner for about 3-5 minutes, or till the bread is frivolously golden.
Flip, Prepare dinner, Serve: I take advantage of a spatula to softly flip the sandwiches over, proceed to cook dinner till the opposite aspect is frivolously golden brown and the cheese has began to soften. I then take away them, minimize them in half, and serve these pickle sandwiches instantly.
My #1 Secret Tip for this dill pickle sandwich recipe is to cook dinner it on low warmth to keep away from burning the bread whereas the cheese melts.
I discover that the key to a very good grilled cheese is the butter on the surface of the bread, and cooking it low and gradual within the pan so the cheese has sufficient time to soften.
From expertise I discovered that when my skillet was too scorching, I ended up with a burnt outdoors and a non-melted inside! Make sure that your butter is mushy and straightforward to unfold, so that you’re in a position to get a skinny layer of butter in your complete sandwich (an excessive amount of butter will make it greasy).
Some folks use mayo as an alternative, however both one will add a pleasant taste to your sandwich and assist it crisp up. You possibly can even use a mix of mayo and butter to get the perfect of each worlds and an ideal crispy sandwich!
Different Suggestions To Maintain In Thoughts:
- Make Certain To Dry The Pickles: I make sure that to dry my pickles totally. In any other case, the surplus moisture could make the bread soggy.
- Don’t Use Too A lot Cheese: Although it’d look like extra cheese could be higher, an excessive amount of cheese can overpower the opposite components. I discover that one thick slice of cheddar cheese per sandwich is ideal for this recipe!
- Pre-Toast Your Bread: I frivolously pre-toast my bread if I would like an additional toasty sandwich. This step additionally helps stop the bread from getting soggy.
- Use Sharp Cheddar: Sharp cheddar has a extra intense taste in comparison with delicate or medium cheddar, which actually makes the sandwich stand out. The sharpness provides a depth of taste that enhances the creamy, wealthy butter and the tangy dill pickles.
- Guarantee The Butter Has Softened: I make sure that the butter is softened to room temperature so it spreads simply on the bread. If the butter is just too exhausting, it might tear the bread when spreading it.
- Attempt A Panini Press: I’ll generally use a panini press for a straightforward approach to grill this sandwich – my youngsters suppose the grill marks are enjoyable, and it ensures the bread and cheese get cooked completely each time with no threat of burning the underside of the bread!
- Serve Instantly, And Serve Sizzling: I at all times serve the pickle cheese sandwich instantly whereas it’s scorching. I don’t suggest grilling it, storing it, and serving it later as a result of the bread received’t be as crispy and the components received’t be as melted and gooey after reheating.
📖 Variations
Once I wish to shake up my grilled cheese sandwich with pickles much more, I’ll check out these variations:
Grilled Cheese With Jalapenos: For extra spice, I swap the pickles for jalapenos. Alternatively, I add jalapenos together with the pickles. For much more warmth, I can embrace scorching sauce or crushed crimson pepper.
Grilled Cheese With Tomato: If I’d quite tone it down and add a cool, recent, and delicate taste to my sandwich, I change the pickles with recent sliced tomato.
Extra Dill Taste: To boost the dill taste, I sprinkle some recent or dried dill over the mayo or add a number of slices of crimson onion earlier than layering with the remaining components.
Decrease Calorie Choice: I take advantage of gentle mayo as an alternative of normal mayo to save lots of about 60 energy and seven grams of fats per sandwich. Moreover, utilizing olive oil cooking spray as an alternative of butter saves about 100 energy and 12 grams of fats. Nonetheless, olive oil cooking spray received’t present the identical moist and crispy crust as butter.
Totally different Bread Or Cheese: I take advantage of any of my favourite breads for this cheese and pickle sandwich recipe and may substitute any form of cheese. Mozzarella, provolone, pepperjack, monterey jack, and even Swiss cheese all work properly. I may use a mix of cheddar and one other cheese for added taste.
Gluten-Free Choice: To make my grilled cheese gluten-free, I merely use my favourite gluten-free bread.
Vegan Choice: To make this pickle and cheese sandwich recipe vegan, I take advantage of vegan bread, vegan mayo, and vegan cheese. The perfect vegan cheese I’ve discovered for grilled cheese is Violife’s Smoked Provolone.
Different Condiments: Fig jam, crimson pepper jelly, ranch, honey, dijon mustard or yellow mustard, fruit preserves, marmalade, and totally different relishes are all nice variations that I experiment with. My husband really likes to make grilled cheese with pickles and mustard!
🍽 Serving Ideas
This sandwich is ideal by itself, but in addition tastes nice when paired with these aspect dishes or a cup of soup! Listed here are a few of my suggestions for pairing:
Soups: For a traditional grilled cheese and soup lunch combo, my vegan minestrone soup, spaghetti squash soup, or vegan hen noodle soup are all comforting pairings.
Lighter Aspect Dishes: I wish to pair this sandwich with my tomato avocado cucumber salad, roasted inexperienced beans and potatoes, this roasted cauliflower salad, or this spinach and arugula salad for a light-weight aspect dish.
🧊 Storing And ♨️ Reheating
This sandwich is actually greatest eaten recent, however listed below are just a few storage choices I like to recommend:
Refrigeration: Utilizing pickles in grilled cheese can create some sogginess so it’s best to eat this sandwich instantly. Once I do have leftovers, I retailer them in an hermetic container within the fridge for 1-2 day.
Reheating: I reheat a leftover sandwich in a skillet or toaster oven till warmed via.
Make Forward: Typically, I’ll make these forward of time (and don’t butter the surface). Then, I retailer them in an hermetic container within the fridge, for as much as 24 hours earlier than cooking. Once I’m able to eat them, I butter the surface, grill the sandwiches, and serve.
❓Recipe FAQs
Utilizing butter (or mayo) on the surface of your grilled cheese is essential to getting it to toast evenly and get that golden brown crispy crust. You want some form of fats because it drastically improves the flavour and texture of the bread because it cooks.
When you don’t butter your grilled cheese, your bread will get toasted, however your sandwich will prove dry and should not cook dinner evenly (and may additionally burn faster). When you completely don’t wish to use butter and want a decrease calorie choice, strive olive oil cooking spray or avocado oil cooking spray as an alternative.
I test if the sandwich is finished by in search of a golden-brown crust and by urgent gently on it to see if the cheese inside is melted. If each side are crispy and the cheese is gooey, it’s able to get pleasure from.
Wish to Save This Recipe?
Enter your e mail & I’ll ship it to your inbox. Plus, get nice new recipes from me each week!
By submitting this type, you consent to obtain emails from The Choosy Eater.
Love this Vegetarian Sandwich recipe? Please go away a 5-star ranking 🌟 within the recipe under and/or a assessment within the remark part additional down the web page!
It’s also possible to FOLLOW ME on FACEBOOK, INSTAGRAM, and PINTEREST to see extra scrumptious, wholesome, family-friendly meals, and when you have any questions, I’m right here to assist!
📋 Recipe Card
Final Grilled Cheese With Pickles (Tangy & Scrumptious!)
My grilled cheese with pickles is the final word alternative for pickle lovers and anybody craving a traditional grilled cheese with a twist. The right mixture of crunchy toasted bread, tangy pickles, and melted, gooey cheese makes this fast and straightforward lunch irresistible.
Servings: 2 sandwiches
Energy: 483kcal
- It’s actually necessary to dry the sliced dill pickles earlier than getting ready the sandwiches so ensure to not skip this step in any other case the liquid will make the bread soggy.
- Any bread can be utilized for the sandwiches corresponding to sourdough, white, multigrain or gluten-free.
- Don’t have the warmth up too excessive because the bread will burn too rapidly and the cheese received’t have time to soften.
- You should utilize different different cheeses as an alternative of cheddar — mozzarella, provolone, pepperjack and even swiss would all work properly.
- So as to add some additional style you’ll be able to strive sprinkling some recent or dried dill over the mayo or add a number of slices of crimson onion earlier than layering with remaining components.
- Make sure the butter has softened to room temperature so it spreads simply on the bread. If the butter is just too exhausting, it might tear the bread when spreading it.
- To make this recipe gluten-free, substitute the wheat bread for gluten-free bread.
- To make this vegan-friendly, substitute the mayo, cheese and butter for vegan pleasant choices.
- Sandwiches might be prepped forward of time and saved, in hermetic container within the fridge, for as much as 24 hours earlier than cooking.
Be aware: Utilizing gentle mayo will minimize the energy and fats. Right here is the dietary data for utilizing gentle mayo as an alternative of normal mayo: 422 Energy, 27g Carbs, 16g Protein, 22g Fats (11g Saturated Fats), 45mg Ldl cholesterol, 1121mg Sodium, 9g Fiber, 4g Sugar.
Serving: 1sandwich | Energy: 483kcal | Carbohydrates: 26g | Protein: 17g | Fats: 29g | Saturated Fats: 13g | Polyunsaturated Fats: 8g | Monounsaturated Fats: 7g | Trans Fats: 0.5g | Ldl cholesterol: 49mg | Sodium: 1094mg | Potassium: 245mg | Fiber: 9g | Sugar: 3g